Reviews of E.l.f. Studio Cream Eyeliner (Black) elf

Customer Ratings:

First, let me start by saying that I normally do not review anything I buy, but I was just really impressed with this eyeliner.

I was a little skeptical about cream eyeliner because the one that I used previously would smudge onto the top of my lid after a couple of hours and so I was looking for a liquid liner (I used to love the Maybelline waterproof liquid liner) but I decided to give E.l.f. a try. I couldn't be happier with my buy.

I've been wearing it for a couple of days now( I love the less exaggerated version of a cat eye) and it has not smudged even once. I live in New England and this past week we've had snow, humidity, rain and my make up has withstood it all. It is creamy enough to go on easily, but dry enough to not smudge during application (and the brush it comes with is way better than the one that comes with the maybelline studio liner). It faded in the shower but didn't completely come off( speaks highly of the waterproofness), but it easily came off with an eye make-up remover I got at the body shop.

Buy this! You will not regret it.

Click Here For Most Helpful Customer Reviews >>

I tested this product out on my waterline. As a stand alone eyeliner, it does not do the job. However, When applied with other products, the staying power on the waterline is incredible. To get eyeliner to stay on my waterline, i first dried my water line with a cotton swab. I then applied a generic pencil liner, then put Elf gel cream eyeliner on top of it, and on top of the Elf gel cream eyeliner, I dipped a small pointed eyeliner brush into black (or whatever color you choose) into eyeshadow and applied it on top. Doing this made the staying power of my eyeliner about 5 hours before i needed to reapply. The Elf cream eyeliner comes in a very small container. Fortunately, a little bit goes a long way. Unfortunately, it is hard to get off of your skin with just water. For example, if you make a mistake while applying it, you will need makeup remover to fix your mistakes.

Best Deals on E.l.f. Studio Cream Eyeliner (Black) elf

I'm a big fan of e.l.f. I fall in love with 75 percent of my purchases and with their prices, that makes me super happy.

This product is a win. Honestly, I've never used a cream eyeliner; but this was everything I was imagining it would be. It was easy to control (my hands are really jittery) and it had staying power even when used without a primer. It was also highly pigmented which is a big deal to me, since my skin is dark and I need my liner to be midnight-BLACK in order to really pop. I didn't get the brush that's pictured with it though, I purchased it directly from the companies site and it isn't pictured on there. I have tons of brushes though (and I've heard less than stellar reviews of the one that people got with it), so it's no big deal. The amount of product in the cute container is pretty good especially for the bargain price.

Honest reviews on E.l.f. Studio Cream Eyeliner (Black) elf

I was so excited to get this after reading the reviews. Putting it on wasn't too difficult, the brush seems decent and it went on smoothly. Well, about an hour after application I looked in the mirror and it was smudged all over! I looked like a raccoon. I didn't touch it, I wasn't sweaty or anything. I've tried it quite a few times and it always ends up smudged all over. Will not buy again, highly disappointed.

Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for E.l.f. Studio Cream Eyeliner (Black) elf

This cream eyeliner is AWESOME! I love it. The black is a true black, the texture is soft and easy to apply and best of all the color does not run or fade! I am really impressed!

It washes off easily with face wash, no extra eye makeup remover needed.

The applicator makes it easy to make thick or thin lines and as long as you keep it clean it seems like it will last. You use a minimal amount of the product during application so this should last probably 10 x's longer than the typical stick eyeliner.

I would definitely recommend this product.

Update:

Since I first purchased this eyeliner I have tried a couple different brands when this wasn't in stock at my local store; what a waste of money. I always go back to this eyeliner and now purchase 2 at a time so I won't run out.

The only con is that it began to dry out before I finished all of the product but for the price and how long it lasts, this eyeliner cannot be beat.

Look for it at Target or on elf.com though; it only costs $3 at those places.