Cheap stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner

Customer Ratings:

I have really oily skin. Without a primer, light office makeup has melted by the afternoon. The smudge stick stays on. I don't need to use a primer, unless I anticipate being in the office late or if I am going out dancing/will be sweating. With a primer, it stays on through showering unless I use eye makeup remover. I have noticed that if I use a deep eye moisturizer the night before, it lingers on my eyelids the next morning and the smudge stick will be melted by noon. I live in California! The melting is not due to humidity.

Click Here For Most Helpful Customer Reviews >>

I actually had to send back and get refunded for the first stila smudge stick in stingray that I purchased because it was defective.It's supposed to move the eyeliner up when you twist it but mine wouldn't twist up at all so I sent it back.So when I got my new one in the mail I tried it and there were no problems like with the previous one.The color is super dark and goes on easily.However it does NOT last very long for me.When I put it on the waterline,within an hour it slips down and looks pretty messy.I had seen really great reviews on this product and that it was long lasting but it just didn't do that for me.Other than that,I do like it and use it occasionally but it is not the best eyeliner I have ever used that's for sure.

Best Deals on stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner

This eyeliner is probably the best I've used ever, and I've tried many. It's a medium brown with some sparkle, so it would be appropriate for day or night. It's also very long lasting, I work long hours and it's lasted my entire shift and then some, about 16.5 hours without smearing or smudging! The only down side is the price, but to me it's worth it!

Honest reviews on stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner

I was extremely excited to see that Stila had an eyeliner in a gorgeous purple color which is my color of choice when it comes to eyeliner. Believe me, I've tried many from L'Oreal to Maybelline to Clinique to a cheap Walgreen's brand. With one exception (L'Oreal), the colors are not true to the pencil.

This is where I need to give Stila props: the color is excellent! The purple is exactly the shade of purple I was hoping for, with an added bonus: a tad bit of glittery goodness. Not too much just enough to stand out.

I am extremely pleased with the color, but not the stick, which is defective. After three days of use, the pencil was worn down so I twisted to the stick in an attempt to get more eyeliner out of it. Nothing came out. I twisted some more. And yet some more. And still some more no luck. The pencil would not drill down from the stick.

I had this same problem with the Moray color as well. This is completely unacceptable, especially since the cost of this cosmetic item is so high. I will not order this product again because of the defective pencils. However, if you'd like to get three days worth of eye popping color, order it you won't be disappointed with the color of the product!

Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner

Excellent eyeliner. Dries very quickly so you will have to be as precise as you can.