Reviews of Benefit Cosmetics Magic Ink Liquid Eyeliner Jet Black

Customer Ratings:

I liked prestige but somehow couldn't find it, so I tried the Elf stuff that is $1 from target, and, well you get what you pay for. The line would be too thick, the pigment was like watercolor. Ew. I tried my sister's and loved it and since I can buy it prime for 12.99, and I would pay twenty as a benefit counter, I plucked it from my own wishlist.

Click Here For Most Helpful Customer Reviews >>

Only eyeliner I have used in years. Tip is nice and small and durable. Lasts all day, unless you rub your eyes of course, looks newly applied for a long time.

Best Deals on Benefit Cosmetics Magic Ink Liquid Eyeliner Jet Black

This is the best eyeliner I have ever had because it does not smudge. It's great for making cat eyes.

Honest reviews on Benefit Cosmetics Magic Ink Liquid Eyeliner Jet Black

I was always under the impression that with epicanthic eyelids, I could not wear liquid eyeliner. Boy was I wrong. Almost 40 years into my life, I decided to give this a try. And I have come to the conclusion that liquid eyeliner is the *ONLY* eyeliner that I can use with my epicanthic eyelids! It isn't liquid after it dries. It's like latex. Like mascara, almost. Which means, when it dries, it does *not* smudge. It doesn't end up on my upper lid, like crayons and oil-based pencils do.

This particular brand was recommended to me by the sales lady at ULTA as her favorite liner, so this is the only liquid eyeliner brand I've ever tried so far, but I am a believer now. She showed me how the brush can be used with different heaviness to create both a thin line, or a heavy line. Awesome control. It's like calligraphy, almost! I can create a Dita von Teese look in less than a minute. Seriously!

The only drawback to this eyeliner, which I found out yesterday, is that it is not waterproof. It is definitely not an eyeliner to use at a funeral, unless you want to create the dramatic watered-down look that Goldie Hawn achieved in "Private Benjamin."

If someone has recommendations for a waterproof liquid eyeliner with the same detail ability, please comment below!!

Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for Benefit Cosmetics Magic Ink Liquid Eyeliner Jet Black

This is the best eyeliner I have ever had. The formula is smudge proof and it glides on nicely. I like that it isn't shiny. I only wish the tip was sharper.